A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention

Cite this

In the context of present-day development, a variety of experiment and research methods and designs exist. This fact is reasoned by the determination of scientists to provide the most comprehensive picture of the topic they explore and cover all the aspects of the problem. In order to pursue this purpose, it is essential to approach even the same issue from different perspectives. The articles A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention on Improving Patients’ Satisfaction, Chronic Drug Treatment among Hemodialysis Patients, Factors Influencing Hand Hygiene Practice of Nursing Students are illustrative in this regard. They demonstrate a variety of methods and designs applied in the studies, which benefit the outcomes of explorations and provide reliable results. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to compare this article in the context of the chosen methods and designs, and estimate the validity of the result.

Cut 15% OFF your first order
We’ll deliver a custom Nursing paper tailored to your requirements with a good discount
Use discount
322 specialists online

A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention on Improving Patients’ Satisfaction

The first article to be analyzed is A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention on Improving Patients’ Satisfaction, written by a large group of scientists. The study implies using a “time series quasi-experimental quantitative design” (Cheng et al., 2018, p. 610). The participants were separated into groups, which were the experimental and the control ones. The first group incurred partnership intervention, while the second one adhered to routine home visits (Cheng et al., 2018).

The level of patient satisfaction was estimated at the beginning of the study, when there was no intervention, six and twelve months after the appliance of the intervention (Cheng et al., 2018). Therefore, the researchers could compare the results and trace their changes for a significant period of time. Such an approach is highly likely to guarantee the reliability and validity of the study results. Therefore, the method and the design of the study are appropriate and match its aims and intended outcomes.

Chronic Drug Treatment among Hemodialysis Patients

The second article intended to be compared is Chronic Drug Treatment among Hemodialysis Patients: A Qualitative Study of Patients, Nursing and Medical Staff Attitudes and Approaches. It should be marked that the authors do not mention a particular design for the study. Considering the objectives set by the researchers and the methods they choose, it may be concluded that it is close to the case-control type. The study is qualitative, and the grounded theory approach presents its foundation (Gilad et al., 2020). The authors stick to “semi-structured, in-depth, interviews with patients and staff from the same dialysis unit studied previously” (Gilad et al., 2020, p. 1). Furthermore, the article covers the cases and staff members of Hadassah Medical Center, which is located in Jerusalem, Israel.

The information presented in the article may be considered to be reliable and trustworthy, as the authors attempt to cover two sides of the issue and conversate both with health care providers and patients. In addition, the semi-structured format of the interview allows to adjust to the dialogue and receive in-depth insight into the person’s experience. However, it is essential to highlight that the study refers to only one medical setting. For this reason, it does not supply a comprehensive picture of chronic drug treatment issues, as the design restricts the scope to only Hadassah Medical Center.

Factors Influencing Hand Hygiene Practice of Nursing Students

Factors Influencing Hand Hygiene Practice of Nursing Students appears to be the last article to be compared to other ones in the context of its methods and design. This study differs from the previously mentioned ones, as it adheres to mixed methods, which are questionnaires, descriptive and inferential analysis, and semi-structured interviews (Zimmerman, 2020). In general, it is descriptive, and it contains two phases (Zimmerman, 2020).

The study refers to a group of students of the Bachelor Nursing program at an Australian university (Zimmerman, 2020). Therefore, although a mixed-method approach is beneficial to revealing all the details of the topic, it may appear to be limited to some extent. The fact that it involves students from the same university and the same program does not contribute to providing a comprehensive picture of the situation. For this reason, this study is reliable and trustworthy only in the context of the Bachelor Nursing program at an Australian university.

On-Time Delivery!
Get your customized and 100% plagiarism-free paper done in as little as 3 hours
Let’s start
322 specialists online

Conclusion

After comparing the aforementioned articles, it is possible to conclude that all of them adhere to different methods and designs depending on the topic of exploration. The chosen approach contributes to providing a comprehensive analysis of the problems and is helpful for covering all the details of it. However, it should be marked that the choice of particular methods and design may limit the results and their significance in some cases.

References

Cheng, J.-F., Huang, X.-Y., Lin, M.-C., Wang, Y.-H., & Yeh, T.-P. (2018). A mental health home visit service partnership intervention on improving patients’ satisfaction. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 32, 610–616. Web.

Gilad, L., Haviv, Y. S., Cohen-Glickman, I., Chinitz, D., & Cohen M. J. (2020). Chronic drug treatment among hemodialysis patients: a qualitative study of patients, nursing and medical staff attitudes and approaches. BMC Nephrology, 21(239), 1-9. Web.

Zimmerman, P.-A. P., Sladdin, I., Shaban, R. Z., Gilbert, J., & Brown, L. (2020). Factors influencing hand hygiene practice of nursing students: A descriptive, mixed-methods study. Nurse Education in Practice, 44. Web.

Comparison Table of Methods and Designs

Article Sample Method Design Reliability/Trustworthy Analysis
Cheng, J.-F., Huang, X. Y., Lin, M.-C., Wang, Y.-H., & Yeh, T.-P. (2018). A mental health home visit service partnership intervention on improvingpatients’ satisfaction. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 32, 610–616. Web. Between groups

The experimental group implied partnership intervention, and the control group adhered to routine home visits. The level of patient satisfaction was estimated before the intervention, and six and twelve months after its appliance.

Quantitative Quasi-experimental Used an adequate sample size. Used appropriate instruments to estimate the results. The methods and design contribute to providing an in-depth insight into the topic and presenting a comprehensive picture.
Gilad, L., Haviv, Y. S., Cohen-Glickman, I., Chinitz, D., & Cohen M. J. (2020). Chronic drug treatment among hemodialysis patients: a qualitative study of patients, nursing and medical staff attitudes and approaches. BMC Nephrology, 21(239), 1-9. Web. The grounded theory approach is applied, and semi-structured and in-depth interviews with patients and staff members were conducted. Qualitative Case-control Used an adequate approach, and the interviews are helpful for covering the chronic drug treatment issues in the chosen setting. The study provides information about chronic drug treatment only in the chosen setting. Therefore, it is highly likely not to reflect the comprehensive picture of the situation.
Zimmerman, P.-A. P., Sladdin, I., Shaban, R. Z., Gilbert, J., & Brown, L. (2020). Factors influencing hand hygiene practice of nursing students: A descriptive, mixed-methods study. Nurse Education in Practice, 44. Web. There was only one group of students enrolled in a Bachelor of Nursing program at an Australian university. Mixed: questionnaire, descriptive and inferential analysis, and semi-structured interviews. Descriptive; two phases. Used an adequate approach, and mixed-method allows to provide an in-depth insight into the topic. The article refers to a particular educational institute, which makes it limited to some extent. In order to cover the issue comprehensively, it is essential to complement the study with other articles.

Cite this paper

Select style

Reference

NursingBird. (2022, August 30). A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention. Retrieved from https://nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/

Reference

NursingBird. (2022, August 30). A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention. https://nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/

Work Cited

"A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention." NursingBird, 30 Aug. 2022, nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/.

References

NursingBird. (2022) 'A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention'. 30 August.

References

NursingBird. 2022. "A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention." August 30, 2022. https://nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/.

1. NursingBird. "A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention." August 30, 2022. https://nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/.


Bibliography


NursingBird. "A Mental Health Home Visit Service Partnership Intervention." August 30, 2022. https://nursingbird.com/a-mental-health-home-visit-service-partnership-intervention/.